"Automation" can be a loaded word in the charity sector.
For many fundraisers and supporter care teams, it sparks a mix of curiosity… and quiet concern. Will it make things feel impersonal? Will we lose that human connection we work so hard to build? Will supporters notice - and care?
That anxiety is completely understandable. Stewardship, after all, is one of the most human parts of what charities do. It's the thank you letter that makes someone feel seen. The follow-up email that arrives at just the right time. The campaign update that shows their gift is making a difference. It's personal. It's emotional. And it builds long-term loyalty.
So when the word "automation" enters the room, it can feel like a threat to that intimacy.
But here's the truth: automation doesn't replace the human touch. It amplifies it.
Think of automation like this:
It's not about removing warmth or empathy - it's about removing friction.
It's about:
- Making sure no supporter gets missed.
- Ensuring thank you emails arrive within minutes, not days.
- Sending event reminders without relying on someone's sticky note system.
- Triggering meaningful, relevant follow-ups based on actual supporter behaviour.
And most importantly, it frees up your team's time to do what they do best: build genuine, creative, strategic relationships with supporters.
Automation isn't cold. But silence is.
You might worry that an automated email feels less sincere than one written by hand.
But imagine being a donor who never gets a thank you.
Or signs up for an event and hears nothing for three weeks.
Or gives monthly and never gets an update.
That's the real risk, and it's happening more often than many charities realise. Not because anyone's failing at their job, but because supporter care teams are stretched to their limits.
Automation steps in not to replace the human, but to protect your team from burnout, and to ensure every supporter gets the experience they deserve.
Automation = consistency + care
Here's what happens when automation and empathy work together:
- Every donor receives a heartfelt thank-you message tailored to their gift type.
- In Memory donors are reminded how much your charity cares.
- Lapsed supporters are re-engaged with a message that resonates.
- Monthly givers feel valued - not just processed.
This isn't less personal. It's more personal, at scale.
Ready to shift the mindset?
If your team is exploring automation but feeling uncertain, start small. Look for low-effort, high-impact wins, like automating welcome journeys or thank-you sequences. Test. Measure. Refine.
Because when done right, automation doesn't distance you from your supporters.
It brings you closer.
Want help turning manual supporter journeys into automated ones - without losing your voice? Let's talk.
Share Article